All societies need citizens who can solve complex problems
and apply knowledge in a variety of contexts as well as citizens who can work
collaboratively to solve problems and communicate solutions to mathematics
education stakeholders. We must educate students to use NCTM’s Process
Standards (NCTM 2000) and move beyond being able to work routine exercises on
standardized tests. We are not educating students for tests; we are educating
them for life. All stakeholders need to see this broader picture and support
teachers in this broader purpose.
Open-ended
questions, as discussed here, are questions that can be solved or explained in
a variety of ways, that focus on conceptual aspects of mathematics, and that
have the potential to expose students’ understanding and misconceptions. NCTM’s
Process Standards—Problem Solving, Reasoning and Proof, Communication, Connections,
and Representation—are difficult to assess with multiple-choice tests. For
example, one aspect of the Communication Standard requires students to
“communicate their mathematical thinking coherently and clearly to peers,
teachers, and others” (NCTM 2000, p. 60). This standard cannot be assessed
through multiple-choice questions. Although
students need to rely on some procedural knowledge to answer this problem, they
have to decide which procedures would apply to it.
WRITING
OPEN-ENDED QUESTIONS
Open-ended
questions can be written using various templates, several of which are
discussed here.
Template
1: What’s Wrong with This?
The earlier
question about expanding (x + 3)2 is an example of this type of question
used to identify errors and misconceptions. We can ask students to identify
errors and explain why they are errors. This template is useful for getting
students to think critically about common misconceptions. Example question
using this template : Bert was trying to graph y = (x – 3)2. He said
that he could simply shift the graph of y = x2 three units to the
left. Convince Bert that his method is incorrect.
Template
2: Create an Example or a Situation
This form of
question is similar to the form of the questions for the game show Jeopardy™.
We give students some parameters and ask them to come up with an example or
situation that fits the parameters. We give them the answer and have them come
up with the question. Example question using this template : Create a system of
linear equations that has the solution (–2, 3). Explain how you determined your
system.
Template
3: Who Is Correct and Why?
This form of
open-ended question—Who is correct and why?—can be used to set up two opposing
arguments. Then students can defend one or the other argument. Example question
using this template : Lucinda thinks that the grades in mathematics class should
be calculated using the mean. Norm thinks that the grades should be calculated
using the median. With whom do you agree and why?
The
templates presented here can be useful in giving teachers a place to start when
writing openended questions, but teachers must be cautious when using them.
Just because a question fits a template does not necessarily mean that the
question is open ended or of high quality.
For example, we
could ask the earlier question in this way:
Jasmine solved x
+ 3 = 5 and got x = 2. Stuartsolved x + 3 = 5 and got x =
8. Who is correct and why?
This form of the
question is no different from askingthe traditional question “Solve x +
3 = 5 for x.” The formulation does not involve the conceptual
underpinnings of equation solving.
The purpose of
schooling from a broader perspective and about preparing students to solve the
kinds of problems that they will encounter in society—not just about preparing
them for standardized tests— so we need different strategies. Open-ended questions
can help teachers focus their instruction and assessment on NCTM’s Process
Standards and on reasoning and sense making, which really is the heart of
mathematics. Moreover responses to open-ended questions give teachers so much
more information about students’ ways of thinking and misconceptions, and these
can provide important avenues for further investigation of mathematics. When students
answer higher-order questions driven by the Process Standards and focused on
meaning, they will be prepared for any test we give them—in school or in life.
Sumber: Mathematics Teacher. Vol. 107, No. 3 ° Oktober 2013
Sumber: Mathematics Teacher. Vol. 107, No. 3 ° Oktober 2013
Tidak ada komentar:
Posting Komentar